itatonline.org Download Center: Download Latest Judgements & Circulars


CIT vs. Agnity India Technologies (Delhi High Court)

Name: CIT vs. Agnity India Technologies (Delhi High Court)
File: agnity_comparable_infosys_high_turnover.pdf
Size: 0.15MB
Extension: PDF
Category: Judgements
Date Uploaded: July 22, 2013
Download Count: 1349
Downloads This Month 1349



Click To Download Now



Synopsis:

Transfer Pricing: Companies with extreme turnover like Infosys are not comparable

The assessee, a wholly owned subsidiary of Bay Packets Inc., USA, was engaged in the business of development of software for the parent company in the field of telecommunications. To determine the arms' length price, the TPO & DRP took Infosys Technologies as a comparable. On appeal by the assessee, the Tribunal (included in file) held that the assessee was not comparable with Infosys as Infosys was a large and bigger company in the area of development of software and the profits earned by it cannot be benchmarked or equated with the assessee's results. One of the aspects pointed out by the Tribunal was that Infosys' turnover was Rs. 9,028 crores while that of the assessee was only Rs. 16.09 crores. On appeal by the department to the High Court, HELD dismissing the appeal:

The Tribunal's findings that Infosys should be excluded from the list of comparables for the reason that (i) Infosys was a giant company and it assumed all risks leading to higher profits, whereas the assessee was a captive unit of the parent company and assumed only a limited risk and (ii) that the financial data (turnover) was not comparable has not been controverted by the Revenue. The Tribunal has given valid and good reasons for excluding Infosys as a comparable. 

Note: This has a bearing on the question whether the turnover filter should be applied which is pending before the Special Bench in Giesecke & Devirent (ITA No.5924/Del/2012)

 

 

--------------------------------


Comments

No comments yet.

Add Comment

* Required information
(will not be published)
 
Bold Italic Underline Strike Superscript Subscript Code PHP Code Quote Insert line Bullet list Numeric list Link Email Image Video
 
Smile Sad Huh Laugh Mad Tongue Crying Grin Wink Scared Cool Sleep Blush Unsure Shocked
 
1000
Out of 56, 14 or 27, which is the smallest?
 
Enter answer:
 
Remember my form details on this computer.
 
 
Powered by Commentics

If you have an unreported judgement which you feel will be useful to the profession, please send it to us at editor (at) itatonline.info